Forest management/Description: Difference between revisions

From IMAGE
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
No edit summary
 
(26 intermediate revisions by 8 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{ComponentSubpageTemplate
{{ComponentDescriptionTemplate
|ExternalModel=EFIGTM
|Reference=Kallio et al., 2004;FAO, 2001a;FAO, 2008;Brown, 2000;Carle and Holmgren, 2008;FAO, 2012b;FAO, 2015;Doelman et al., 2019;Dagnachew et al., 2020;ESA, 2017;FAO, 2020
|Reference=Kallio et al., 2004; Arets et al., 2010; FAO, 2001; FAO, 2009; FAO, 2010;  Brown 1990; Carle and Holmgren 2008
}}
|Description=Forest harvest  in IMAGE is driven by the timber demand per region. This demand is the sum of the domestic demand and the net import of timber. Trade is accounted for by either external models, such as EFI-GTM ([[Kallio et al., 2004]]). Logging in a region continues until the timber demand is met. A stepwise procedure is designed to attribute shares of the total demand to the different management systems. Part of the demand for timber is fulfilled by the harvest of wood from the conversion of forests to agriculture. Next, all full-grown wood plantations (at the end of their rotation cycle) of a region are harvested. Plantations are used first, as these have been established on purpose and significant investments have been made. When this harvested amount is not enough to supply the demand, other management systems are used. This can be either done by applying clear-cut cycles in semi-natural forests or by selective logging of heterogeneous forests. The share of each system is derived from inventories in different world region.
<div class="page_standard">
[[File:ForestManagementModel.png|thumbnail|right|200px|alt=Component flow chart forest management|Flow diagram of forest management]]
<h3>Rotation cycle logging</h3>
Per year, region and vegetation type is defined what fraction of the forests is logged by selective cut and what part is logged by clear cut (parameters from inventory by [[Arets et al., 2010]]). Selective cut only takes place on vegetation types with a high forest coverage (>75%). After logging only a fraction of the harvested wood is actually removed as timber for the market. What is left behind in the forest represents the losses during tree harvesting, either from unintended collateral tree damage or by removing unusable tree parts. Harvest in any forest management type can only take place when the rotation cycle of regrowth of a forest is completed (see table).


[[File:CycleLogging.png|thumb|240px|right|alt=Table describing the rotation cycles for forest management types in different forests|Table: Rotation cycles for forest management types in different forest biomes.]]
The forest management module describes regional timber demand and the production of timber in the three different management systems clear felling, selective felling and forest plantations. Deforestation rates reported by {{abbrTemplate|FAO}} and double-checked by satellite-based estimates from ESA-CCI land cover data ([[ESA, 2017]]) are used to calibrate deforestation rates in IMAGE, using a so-called additional deforestation factor resulting in additional degraded forest area.


===Timber demand===
In IMAGE 3.2, the driver for forest harvest is timber demand per region. Timber demand is the sum of domestic and/or regional demand and timber claims by other regions (export/trade). Production and trade assumptions for saw logs and paper/pulp wood are based on simple historical relationships between population, GDP and timber use per capita ([[Doelman et al., 2018]]). Domestic demand for fuelwood is based on the [[TIMER model]] (See Component [[Energy supply and demand]]) ([[Dagnachew et al., 2020]]).


<h3>Fuel wood</h3>
Part of the global energy supply is met by fuelwood and charcoal, in particular in less developed world regions. Not all wood involved is produced from formal forestry activities, as it is also collected from non-forest areas, for example from thinning orchards and along roadsides ([[FAO, 2001a]]; [[FAO, 2008]]). As few reliable data are available on fuelwood production, own assumptions have been made in IMAGE. While fuelwood production in industrialized regions is dominated by large-scale, commercial operations, in transitional and developing regions smaller proportions of fuelwood volumes are assumed to come from forestry operations: 50% and 32% respectively.  
Part of the energy needs of the regional population is fulfilled with wood, called fuelwood. Only part of the fuelwood is harvested by industrial forestry activities, and can be coupled to the described management systems above.  There are several informal ways to produce and collect fuelwood, next to industrial production: orchards, roadsides, forest management residues after timber removal, etc ([[FAO, 2001]]; [[FAO, 2009]]). Exact data on informal fuelwood production are missing, and therefore assumptions have been made. In the developed regions, it is assumed that fuelwood is produced on industrial scales and therefore all fuel wood demand is added to the timber demand. In the transitional regions 50% of the fuel wood demand is coming from timber and in the developing regions 32%.  


<h3>Establishing wood plantations</h3>
===Timber supply & production in forests===
Wood plantations are established on purpose to provide specific wood qualities in an efficient way. The expectation is that in future, more and more wood will be produced from plantations. For this, plantation planting rate scenarios have been drawn up by FAO ([[Brown 1990]]; [[Carle and Holmgren 2008]]). In the IMAGE model wood plantations are established on abandoned agricultural land, and this process can be called reforestation. If there is not enough abandoned land, they will be established on clear-cut forest areas, where the forest coverage of the original natural vegetation type should be more than 75%.  A wood plantation is specifically planted for roundwood or for pulpwood. Once a wood plantation is established this area cannot be used for other purposes, and it cannot change back to natural vegetation until after the rotation cycle and subsequent wood removal.
In IMAGE, felling in each region follows a stepwise procedure until timber demand is met, attributed to the three management systems. The proportion for each management system is derived from forest inventories for different world regions ([[Arets et al., 2011]]) and used as model input (Figure Flowchart). Firstly, timber is derived from forest land that has been converted to agriculture. Secondly, timber from forest plantations at the end of their rotation cycle are harvested. Finally, trees from natural forests are harvested, applying clear felling and/or selective felling. In all management systems, trees can only be harvested when the rotation cycle of forest regrowth has been completed.


<h3>Additional deforestation</h3>
===Selective logging===
A special type of forest use in IMAGE is the so-called “additional” deforestation.
Under selective felling, only a - regional and time specific- fraction of the trees is logged and the other trees remain in the forest. After logging, a fraction of the harvested wood is removed from the forest to fulfil the demand. Biomass left behind in the forest represents losses/residues during tree harvesting (from tree damage and unusable tree parts) or left in the forest because of environmental concerns (biodiversity and nutrient supply). This fraction take-away is derived from literature, defined for industrial roundwood (see [[Arets et al., 2011]]) It is further adjusted to account for the demand for wood fuel, for which it equals unity.
With this additional deforestation extra areas of forest are converted in addition to the deforestation in IMAGE caused by agricultural expansion. This process is included as a correction factor, and is due to unmodelled conversion. Additional deforestation is not a forest management type because the wood is not used for timber but the process  is part of the forest management module. The areas are slashed and the wood is left behind in regions with higher latitudes and burned down at the lower latitudes. No recovery to natural vegetation takes place in these areas and no agricultural activities can be started. Logging for additional deforestation in a region only starts after the demand for timber is satisfied.


The additional deforestation is driven by the difference of the regional deforestation data of the ([[FAO, 2010]]) and the agricultural expansion data of the IMAGE land use model .
===Forest plantations===
}}
Forest plantations are established for efficient, commercially viable wood production. Their regional establishment in IMAGE 3 is scenario driven (see also Input/Output Table at [[Forest management|Introduction part]]), based on FAO. The expectation is that increasingly more wood will be produced in plantations because sustainability criteria may limit harvest from natural forests ([[Brown, 2000]]; [[Carle and Holmgren, 2008]]; [[FAO, 2012b]]). Forest plantations are assumed to be established firstly on abandoned agricultural land. When sufficient abandoned land is not available, forest plantations are established on cleared forest areas. When a forest plantation has been established, the land cannot be used for other purposes or converted to natural vegetation until the tree rotation cycle has been completed. Forest growth rates are modelled in LPJmL and calibrated to empirical data ([[Braakhekke et al., 2019]]).
 
===Additional deforestation ===
Globally, conversion to agricultural land is the major driver of forest clearing; timber harvest does not result in deforestation, if natural vegetation is regrowing. But there are other causes of deforestation not related to food demand and timber production, such as urbanization, mining and illegal logging. These activities contribute to loss of forest area, increased degradation risks and a decline in the supply of forest services. To account for this, deforestation rates are calibrated to FAO reported deforestation rates that are consistent with observed deforestation from satellite-based land cover time series from ESA-CCI ([[ESA, 2017]]). The additional category used for this calibration is called ‘additional deforestation’. IMAGE assumes no recovery of natural vegetation in these areas and no agricultural activities.
</div>

Latest revision as of 19:14, 22 November 2021

Model description of Forest management

The forest management module describes regional timber demand and the production of timber in the three different management systems clear felling, selective felling and forest plantations. Deforestation rates reported by FAO and double-checked by satellite-based estimates from ESA-CCI land cover data (ESA, 2017) are used to calibrate deforestation rates in IMAGE, using a so-called additional deforestation factor resulting in additional degraded forest area.

Timber demand

In IMAGE 3.2, the driver for forest harvest is timber demand per region. Timber demand is the sum of domestic and/or regional demand and timber claims by other regions (export/trade). Production and trade assumptions for saw logs and paper/pulp wood are based on simple historical relationships between population, GDP and timber use per capita (Doelman et al., 2018). Domestic demand for fuelwood is based on the TIMER model (See Component Energy supply and demand) (Dagnachew et al., 2020).

Part of the global energy supply is met by fuelwood and charcoal, in particular in less developed world regions. Not all wood involved is produced from formal forestry activities, as it is also collected from non-forest areas, for example from thinning orchards and along roadsides (FAO, 2001a; FAO, 2008). As few reliable data are available on fuelwood production, own assumptions have been made in IMAGE. While fuelwood production in industrialized regions is dominated by large-scale, commercial operations, in transitional and developing regions smaller proportions of fuelwood volumes are assumed to come from forestry operations: 50% and 32% respectively.

Timber supply & production in forests

In IMAGE, felling in each region follows a stepwise procedure until timber demand is met, attributed to the three management systems. The proportion for each management system is derived from forest inventories for different world regions (Arets et al., 2011) and used as model input (Figure Flowchart). Firstly, timber is derived from forest land that has been converted to agriculture. Secondly, timber from forest plantations at the end of their rotation cycle are harvested. Finally, trees from natural forests are harvested, applying clear felling and/or selective felling. In all management systems, trees can only be harvested when the rotation cycle of forest regrowth has been completed.

Selective logging

Under selective felling, only a - regional and time specific- fraction of the trees is logged and the other trees remain in the forest. After logging, a fraction of the harvested wood is removed from the forest to fulfil the demand. Biomass left behind in the forest represents losses/residues during tree harvesting (from tree damage and unusable tree parts) or left in the forest because of environmental concerns (biodiversity and nutrient supply). This fraction take-away is derived from literature, defined for industrial roundwood (see Arets et al., 2011) It is further adjusted to account for the demand for wood fuel, for which it equals unity.

Forest plantations

Forest plantations are established for efficient, commercially viable wood production. Their regional establishment in IMAGE 3 is scenario driven (see also Input/Output Table at Introduction part), based on FAO. The expectation is that increasingly more wood will be produced in plantations because sustainability criteria may limit harvest from natural forests (Brown, 2000; Carle and Holmgren, 2008; FAO, 2012b). Forest plantations are assumed to be established firstly on abandoned agricultural land. When sufficient abandoned land is not available, forest plantations are established on cleared forest areas. When a forest plantation has been established, the land cannot be used for other purposes or converted to natural vegetation until the tree rotation cycle has been completed. Forest growth rates are modelled in LPJmL and calibrated to empirical data (Braakhekke et al., 2019).

Additional deforestation

Globally, conversion to agricultural land is the major driver of forest clearing; timber harvest does not result in deforestation, if natural vegetation is regrowing. But there are other causes of deforestation not related to food demand and timber production, such as urbanization, mining and illegal logging. These activities contribute to loss of forest area, increased degradation risks and a decline in the supply of forest services. To account for this, deforestation rates are calibrated to FAO reported deforestation rates that are consistent with observed deforestation from satellite-based land cover time series from ESA-CCI (ESA, 2017). The additional category used for this calibration is called ‘additional deforestation’. IMAGE assumes no recovery of natural vegetation in these areas and no agricultural activities.